A New Heartbeat is Coming to Benton County
00 d
:
00 h
:
00 m
:
00 s

Eagles VS Data Center: Residents Fear Project Could Disturb Nests

Posted

A proposed data center near Warsaw is raising questions about more than electricity, water use, and development. For some Benton County residents, the concern is about bald eagles that have made the area their home for years.

Residents say the birds have returned to nesting sites near the proposed development, and they want to know what could happen if a data center is built nearby.

George Hall, a longtime Benton County resident and property owner, is among those raising concerns. Hall recently sent a four-page letter dated Nov. 2 to Trent Overhue of NSI 6, LLC, the company associated with the proposed development.

The letter addresses several issues, but one of Hall's biggest concerns involves bald eagles nesting near the property.

During a telephone interview, Hall said he knows of two nesting locations in the general area, one north and another south of the proposed site.

"I went and looked at the one north the other day. There's got a bald eagle there right now," Hall said.

He said the other nest has been used by a breeding pair for as long as he can remember.

"The one south of it, I've been here 30 years, and I know for a fact it's used every spring by a mating pair of bald eagles," Hall said.

Hall believes the nesting sites are within approximately half a mile of the proposed development. His letter places at least one nest within three-quarters of a mile of the property.

His concern is whether noise and activity associated with a data center could interfere with the birds' nesting and breeding habits.

Under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act, bald eagles and their nests receive federal protection. Certain activities that disturb the birds may require authorization from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

However, a nearby eagle nest does not automatically prohibit construction. Whether a project requires a permit depends on the activity, its location and the potential disturbance to the birds.

Hall wants to know whether the developer has studied those possible effects.

In his letter, Hall asks what studies have been conducted to determine whether noise from the proposed data center could disturb the nesting eagles. He also questions whether any necessary federal permits have been obtained.

"Well, does he have a permit? That's a good question," Hall said.

Those questions have not been independently resolved. Hall said he would welcome an opportunity to discuss his concerns directly with Overhue in public.

"Why doesn't he come to Benton County? I'll get the building. Let's have an open debate and forum on it to the public," Hall said.

For Rosa and Gerald Valentine, who moved to Benton County from Liberal, Kansas, about nine years ago, the issue also hits close to home. The couple said they chose the Warsaw area because of its lakes, wildlife, and quieter surroundings.

Rosa Valentine said protecting the eagles is especially important to her.

"We're concerned because, you know, it's a half mile from where he's wanting to put the data center, and the eagles are the bird of the United States," she said. She believes the nesting site has been there for more than a decade, although she acknowledged that information came from others who have lived in the area longer. "That actual nest has been here for over ten years, from what I've been told," Valentine said.

She is particularly concerned about the birds returning to nest in the spring. "And in March, they're going to hatch," she said, referring to the expected nesting season.

The actual nesting and hatching schedule would depend on the birds and seasonal conditions.

For Valentine, the issue is personal because the area's natural surroundings were among the reasons she and her husband moved to Missouri.

"Oh, the lakes and the nature of things here, the quietness, not such a busy, busy, environment like in the city," she said.

Gerald Valentine also expressed concern about possible environmental effects from the development, including potential impacts on surrounding waterways and wildlife.

He said the couple began attending Benton County Commission meetings earlier this year after learning about possible data center development in the area.

While their concerns extend to water quality and the local environment, the nearby eagle nesting sites remain a particular worry.

Rosa Valentine has also organized a private Facebook group called We the People of Benton County, where residents discuss the proposed project and share information about county meetings.

She encouraged residents to become involved and make their concerns known.

"Everybody needs to start speaking up," she said.

Hall, meanwhile, has gone a step further with his written notice to Overhue.

His Nov. 2 letter includes a notice of intent to sue and a notice of intent to file a lis pendens, a legal notice generally associated with litigation affecting real property. The letter does not, by itself, establish that a lawsuit has been filed or that the developer has violated federal wildlife protections.

As residents continue seeking answers, Hall said a public protest is being planned in Springfield on Friday, Nov. 20, from 11 AM to 2 PM at the intersection of Sunshine Street and Glenstone Avenue. The gathering is intended to give residents from Benton County and surrounding communities an opportunity to express their concerns about data center development and encourage public discussion.

Hall said residents from Greene, Webster and other Missouri counties are welcome to participate.

The planned gathering comes as questions remain about the proposed development, including the precise locations of the eagle nests, whether environmental assessments have been conducted and whether the project would create any disturbance requiring federal authorization. Those questions would require information from the developer and appropriate wildlife officials.

For Hall and the Valentines, the issue comes down to protecting something they believe makes Benton County special. The eagles have been part of the landscape for years. They want to make sure those birds will continue returning long after the debate over the proposed data center is settled.

The Enterprise reached out to Trent Overhue for this article. At press time, no response had been received. We would welcome an interview with him.